ISSN (Print) - 0012-9976 | ISSN (Online) - 2349-8846

A+| A| A-

Limited Imagination on Reservation

Supreme Court’s judgment to base subcategorisation on the creamy layer logic for Scheduled Castes is simplistic.

Anup Surendranath writes:

In August 2020, a five-judge constitution bench in Davinder Singh vs State of Punjab referred the constitutional permissibility of sub-classification of Scheduled Castes (SCs) to a seven-judge bench. In a judgment authored by Justice Arun Mishra, the bench opined that the Supreme Courts judgment in E V Chinnaiah (November 2004) disallowing sub-classification of SCs required reconsideration and that sub-classification was required to ensure fair distribution of reservations. Arguably, Davinder Singh adopts a constitutionally unsustainable reasoning in coming to its conclusion. By using reasoning that collapses the difference between Other Backward Classes (OBCs) and SCs, the judgment perpetuates the error in Jarnail Singhs case (September 2018) by paving the way to further entrench creamy layer for SCs in our constitutional jurisprudence. Further, in adopting a rather simplistic understanding of disparities in distribution of reservation benefits among SCs, it fails to engage with the substantive equality questions that lie at the heart of this issue. 

Dear Reader,

To continue reading, become a subscriber.

Explore our attractive subscription offers.

Click here

Or

To gain instant access to this article (download).


Pay
INR 59

(Readers in India)


Pay
$ 6

(Readers outside India)

Published On : 12th Jan, 2024

Support Us

Your Support will ensure EPW’s financial viability and sustainability.

The EPW produces independent and public-spirited scholarship and analyses of contemporary affairs every week. EPW is one of the few publications that keep alive the spirit of intellectual inquiry in the Indian media.

Often described as a publication with a “social conscience,” EPW has never shied away from taking strong editorial positions. Our publication is free from political pressure, or commercial interests. Our editorial independence is our pride.

We rely on your support to continue the endeavour of highlighting the challenges faced by the disadvantaged, writings from the margins, and scholarship on the most pertinent issues that concern contemporary Indian society.

Every contribution is valuable for our future.