January 14, 2006

From the PM, for the Drylands
A
The prime minister’s inaugural address at the Congress action through a National Rainfed Areas Authority that the showed an acute awareness of this crisis. Speaking of prime minister spoke about in his address to the nation last the “agricultural growth plateau”, Manmohan Singh independence day. Such an authority must be professionally acknowledged that the “technologies and strategies run with clear accountability for performance. It needs to unleashed by the first green revolution have run their course”. be provided great operational autonomy. The Parthasarathy He spoke of the need for a second green revolution with a committee set up by the ministry of rural development is special focus on dryland agriculture and small and marginal apparently working out the details of such a proposal. This farmers. The 1990s saw negative rates of growth of output needs urgent attention at the highest levels of decision-making. of all dryland crops – not just coarse cereals and pulses, The prime minister’s emphasis in his speech on equity, but oilseeds as well. The prime minister drew attention to sustainability and decentralisation of development and what some regard as the single most important macro-governance was refreshing. What is required is the locationeconomic statistic of the Indian economy – the share of the specific application of these principles, which have to be working population dependent on agriculture has shown a the building blocks for his “New Deal to Rural India”. Within remarkable stability when compared to the share of agri-this, his mention of interlinking of rivers struck a jarring culture in national income that has declined rapidly since note. There was a call for a more informed debate on the independence. As the prime minister said “the only sensible issue to ensure “ecologically sustainable and economically response to this trend is to create productive employment affordable utilisation of river waters”. Such a debate would opportunities in rural areas”. He called upon the scientists have to begin by recognising that the scheme is estimated to devise appropriate and affordable, labour-using techno-to cost around Rs 5,60,000 crore. Worse, it could be an logies for energy and water, especially designed for farmers ecological disaster. Respected scientists explain that the of drought-prone regions. The emphasis on solar energy and presence of a low-salinity, low-density layer of water helps biomass in the prime minister’s speech was heartening. maintain high sea-surface temperatures in the Bay of Bengal.
Manmohan Singh strongly endorsed the five-point It is the consequent development of a low-pressure system
programme suggested by the M S Swaminathan-headed that intensifies summer monsoon activity in the Bay of
National Commission on Farmers. This includes addressing Bengal. Shutting off the flow of water could threaten this
low-salinity layer with grave long-term consequences for climate and rainfall in the subcontinent, endangering the livelihoods of a vast population. To move ahead on the river-linking programme without sound and credible scientific data on the monsoon system that takes into account all possible air-sea-land-life interactions, would indeed be foolhardy. The prime minister would be welladvised to concentrate on the principles he outlined in his address and avoid rushing into ideas lacking scientific credibility. EPW
Economic and Political Weekly January 14, 2006
Comments
EPW looks forward to your comments. Please note that comments are moderated as per our comments policy. They may take some time to appear. A comment, if suitable, may be selected for publication in the Letters pages of EPW.