A+| A| A-

Indian Development-A Different Soviet View

 term 'community' would be helpful, as it is used at a number of different levels in these essays. The study of the Bombay textile workers is highly suggestive, but it lacks the precision of focus on working class culture seen in the writings of Dipesh Chakrabarty on the jute-workers of Calcutta. In fact, Kumar is only too well aware (p 58) of the problem involved in understanding popular culture and consciousness, and he calls for studies of the quality of those carried by Oscar Lewis in Mexico, It is a pity, perhaps, that he himself did not follow this suggestion up. His belief that peasant jacqueries are spontaneous outbursts (p 215) needs to be modified after the appearance of Ranajit Guha's monograph, "Elementary Aspects of Peasant Insurgency in Colonial India", which shows that from the peasant's own point of view there is nothing 'spontaneous' about such revolts. At times, Kumar uses rather elitist language, as on page 68, where he says that 'King Mob ruled over the city' (of Bombay) and 'primitive passions' were set loose. Why, one wonders, is it 'primitive' for workers to attack with ferocity those whom they see as their exploiters? Where the police also guilty of giving vent to their 'primitive passions' when they suppressed the rioters with lathis unci bullets?

To read the full text Login

Get instant access

New 3 Month Subscription
to Digital Archives at

₹826for India

$50for overseas users


(-) Hide

EPW looks forward to your comments. Please note that comments are moderated as per our comments policy. They may take some time to appear. A comment, if suitable, may be selected for publication in the Letters pages of EPW.

The Past at Every Corner Delhi: Ancient History edited by Upinder Singh; Social Science Press, New Delhi,
Shonaleeka Kaul Delhi: Ancient...

Women and the Politics of Class by Johanna Brenner

Explorations in Pragmatic Economics Selected papers of George A Akerlof

This paper re-examines the monetary aggregation procedure in India in the context of the new monetary aggregates proposed by the Third Working...

characterisations, and it must be admitted that his writing does smack of overkill, the problem remains. How do we explain the continued...

Harsh Sethi Development, Ethnicity and Human Rights in South Asia by Ross Mallick; Sage Publications, Delhi, 1998; pp 375, Rs 425.

on the part of the Bengali middle class to de-class their identity through the praxis of the stage has its thrills, even as the tragedy it...

Ashok Mitra The Mirror of Class: Essays on Bengali Theatre by Himani Bannerji; Papyrus, Calcutta, 1998; pp 240, Rs 200.
IT would be an...

Failed Idealism Anirudh Deshpande J P: His Biography by Allan and Wendy Scarfe (revised edition); Orient Longman, New Delhi, 1998; pp 274 (21...

Back to Top