ISSN (Print) - 0012-9976 | ISSN (Online) - 2349-8846

DiscussionSubscribe to Discussion


Reply Bagaram Tulpule SAHAB DAVAL is angry at what he considers to be my 'harsh and indelicate comments' and, by implication, at my not using proper language and not avoiding personal overtones. It is a matter of opinion whether my words quoted by him towards the end of his rejoinder constitute any linguistic impropriety or indelicacy when used by a reviewer in relation to the book he reviews, But there is no question of any 'personal overtones' being involved. It is usual for a reviewer to refer to the author by name in his comments, but the comments themselves are about what the author writes in the book and not about the author himself personally. My only acquaintance with Sahab Dayal is through his present book and there is no reason whatsoever why I should make any adverse remarks about him personally.

Movements for Higher Agricultural Prices-A Comment

April 4, 1981 have no wish to comment on the 'grudge' I am alleged to bear towards Indians settled abroad; on the excel- lence or distinguished quality of the work they are stated to be doing, oh the extensive research Dayal claims to have made for writing his book or on the ''principles of scholarly scrutiny widely shared by the intellectual community''.

Industrial Relations from a Distance-Comment

Industrial Relations from a Distance Comment Sahab Dayal IN his review of my book Bagaram Tulpule (February 6) grossly and unfairly misrepresents the book via a careless and irresponsible use of selected sentences and statements, that are both out of context and distorted. Let me respond point by point.

Little Nationalism Turned Chauvinist-A Comment

Little Nationalism Turned Chauvinist A Comment Gail Omvedt AMALENDU GUHA'S defence of the left front' position on Assam (EPW welcome because it is the most detailed effort yet by a Marxist academic expert. If such a presentation cannot stand up to empirical evidence or logic, then I would think it is a good indication that the basic political position is itself indefensible.

Limited Interconnection

Limited Interconnection Hansavivek TA TA ELEC TRIC Companies' chairman, N H Tata, has urged formulation of a scheme for interconnection to ensure full utilisation of national resources to prevent the periodical local deficits caused by the vagaries of the monsoon and to effect economy by keeping the power costs to the consumers to a minimum. Interconnections were established by Maharashtra State Electricity Board with the power systems of Eastern Maharashtra, MP, Mysore and Gujarat, but Tata says that the assistance available was inadequate and much less than the optimum, apart from initial difficulties and limitations in the interconnecting facilities. On their part the three Tata companies had undertaken a programme of modernisation and rehabilitation of the thermal station at Trombay, Work on the third 62.5 MW unit was completed, and the station with a total capability of approximately 330 MW was consistently maintained at a high level of efficiency. Throughout the period of power-cut the 4 units were operated at the highest possible load factor. The Trombay thermal station generated 213 million units per month in May and June 1969 which was not only the highest generation at the station so far but represented 92 per cent of its capability. The companies have increased their rates by 20 per cent from September following increase of 33 per cent in bulk supply charges by MSEB from the preceding month. Government has recently set up an expert committee to recommend measures for optimum utilisation of national resources and improving efficiency of power systems in India. Tata Electric Companies, general manager, K M Chinnappa, is a member of the committee.


Back to Top